CMT claims breakthrough in early detection of cylinder scuffing

CMT Scuffing Sensors have been developed to provide early warning of sudden severe cylinder wear. [Photo: CMT]

Glueckstadt, Germany-headquartered engine monitoring specialist CM Technologies (CMT) says that ships’ trials have confirmed that its new scuffing sensor can detect early onset cylinder wear, preventing significant damage to two-stroke marine diesel engines, costly repairs and downtime.

Trials onboard a number of large containerships and a two-stroke engine powered Baltic ferry showed it was possible to measure the friction in the cylinder when the engine is running, something that has not before been possible.

Scuffing —extreme wear following breakdown or failure of the lubricating film between the piston rings and cylinder liner—can cost upwards of $100,000 per cylinder to repair. It can also result in catastrophic engine failure and substantial revenue loss.

“One of the big problems for the reliable detection of sudden severe liner wear is that the long running time of a marine diesel engine has made it virtually impossible to visually detect scuffing as it happens,” said CMT managing director Matthias Winkler. “When sudden severe liner wear occurs, piston damage is quick, spontaneous and without warning. Current methods such as drain oil analysis, liner wall temperature monitoring and visual port inspections are inadequate as they indicate something is wrong when it’s too late. Timing is crucial. The technology we have developed alerts operators with enough time to be able to do something about it.”

While catastrophic engine damage is rare, CMT is noticing a worrying trend in cylinder liner scuffing following the widespread use of 0-0.50% low sulfur fuel (LSF). These fuels together with insufficient or over lubrication, wrong feed rates or incorrect cylinder oil Base Number (BN) can see the oil film breakdown, causing adhesion, micro welds, corrosion, abrasion and metal-to-metal contact.

Similarly, advancements in combustion engine technology have required engines to operate with increased power density, higher loads, and higher combustion pressures and temperatures – parameters that result in a more demanding combustion and lubrication environment.

“When running engines on low sulfur fuels, the acidity created during combustion is lower,” says Winkler. “This results in a smoother liner surface that is difficult to establish a consistent, effective lubricating film, potentially causing metal-on-metal contact.”

According to a CMT survey of 70 shipowners operating large two-stroke engines running on LSF, 67% reported lube oil related problems. Of these, 72.9% reported cylinder scuffing problems and 691.4% higher than normal liner wear rates.

To better alert operators to the condition of cylinder liners during engine operation, CMT embarked on a research project to develop a reliable, rapid detection technology that uses state-of-the-art acoustic emissions sensors to analyse the operating environment within the piston cylinder.

With no need to stop the engine to take readings, the sensor detects changes in high frequency vibration and stress waves when accumulated energy is rapidly released on the piston rings and cylinder liner’s surface.

CMT’s AE sensors – electromagnetic acoustic transducers with built-in amplifiers optimized to detect sound waves in the 300 to 700kHz range – expose and locate material crack formation, friction, delamination and cavitation, revealing underlying problems with the lubricant being used. Data is analyzed by the company’s proprietary software.

“Sudden severe wear of piston rings and cylinder liners causes enormous damage to two-stroke engines, but conventional detection methods fail to provide enough warning,” says Winkler. “Ship operators now have a unique, quick, reliable and proven wear detection solution capable to showing when oil lubrication fails, and when structural repairs are necessary before it’s too late.”

Following the successful completion of field trials, CMT is now marketing its scuffing sensor industry wide.